Video Summary

Scott Galloway: Why Young Men Are Falling Behind | PBD #758

PBD Podcast

Main takeaways
01

Young men face a mental-health crisis — men account for roughly 4 of every 5 suicides cited in the conversation.

02

Loss of male role models (divorce, death, abandonment) is a key single-point failure for boys.

03

K–12 systems and classroom norms often disadvantage boys; vocational on-ramps have declined.

04

Technology and social media increase isolation and reduce opportunities for real-life connection.

05

Economic barriers — housing, education costs, and policy tilt toward older cohorts — hinder young men’s independence and mating prospects.</br>

Key moments
Questions answered

What single factor does Galloway identify as the common failure point when boys 'come off the tracks'?

He says the single point of failure is losing a male role model — through divorce, death, or abandonment — which sharply worsens outcomes for boys.

How does the K–12 system disadvantage boys, according to the discussion?

Galloway argues classrooms favor traits where girls generally mature earlier and excel; fewer male teachers, less vocational programming, and disciplinary practices can unfairly penalize boys.

What role does technology play in young men’s struggles?

Social media and digital platforms sequester attention, erode face-to-face relationships, and contribute to anxiety, depression, and social withdrawal among young men.

What practical short-term steps does Galloway suggest for men seeking to improve dating prospects?

He recommends the 'rule of threes': work out three+ times per week, engage in activities outside the house, and work outside the home — behaviors that markedly increase social and dating opportunities.

What is Galloway’s core financial advice for young people aiming for long-term wealth?

Find a field where you can be in the top 1%, commit long-term (20–30 years), practice financial discipline, and regularly invest in low-cost index funds.

The Struggles of Young Men in Society 00:06

"If you go into a morgue and there are five people who have died by suicide, four are men."

  • The alarming statistic highlights a significant issue: a troubling number of young men are struggling with mental health, leading to a high suicide rate. The statement reinforces the seriousness of the challenges faced by young men today, marking a growing crisis.

  • Scott Galloway emphasizes the lack of positive male role models and how losing these figures can cause boys to falter on their path to manhood. This absence contributes to a broader societal failure to support young men during their developmental years.

Factors Contributing to Male Loneliness and Alienation 02:44

"20% of men aged 25 to 34 live with their parents, up from 14% a decade ago."

  • There is a concerning trend of increased dependency among young men, as shown by the rising number of those living at home with their parents. This statistic reflects broader societal and economic issues contributing to male isolation and inability to establish independent lives.

  • Young men are experiencing deepening social disconnection, with 15% reporting that they have zero close friends, a stark increase compared to previous decades. This loneliness is compounded by economic challenges and the perception that traditional avenues for success and companionship have diminished.

The Dual Impact on Young Men's Success 06:29

"Our tax policy has effectively transferred wealth from young people to old people."

  • Galloway points to systemic issues that disadvantage younger generations economically. These policies have perpetuated wealth inequality, making it increasingly difficult for young men to achieve financial stability and independence, which in turn affects their social standing.

  • He remarks on the detrimental impact of escalating housing and education costs, which are critical factors in establishing economic independence and finding suitable partners. The combination of these elements creates barriers to success that disproportionately affect young men.

The Absence of Role Models and Empathy 05:40

"There are symbols of masculinity everywhere."

  • Galloway argues that while there are positive examples of masculinity, the overall societal perception often overlooks them. He believes that individuals who embody these traits in everyday life can serve as important role models, yet many young men feel disconnected from these ideals.

  • He critiques both far-left and far-right narratives for failing to provide constructive support. Instead of blaming young men or promoting regressive views, he calls for more empathy and understanding regarding their struggles.

The Importance of Challenging Young Men 02:10

"We don't have enough voices of men that are good examples and challenging boys to become men."

  • Galloway stresses the necessity for more constructive discussions about masculinity, advocating for positive male figures who can inspire and guide young boys through mentorship.

  • He underscores the need to foster important values like hard work, loyalty, and resilience, guiding young men towards achieving their potential through meaningful examples and support systems.

The Importance of Purpose in Fatherhood 09:28

"My purpose is to raise loving, patriotic men."

  • Scott Galloway emphasizes the significant role of fatherhood, noting that his purpose in life shifted from selfishness to raising strong, loving sons. He believes that men who serve loyally and patriotically often find fulfillment in raising their children.

The Rising Anxiety Among Children 10:11

"Parents use so many sanitary wipes on their lives that they don't develop their own immunities."

  • The discussion touches on the detrimental effects of overprotective parenting styles, which can hinder children from facing challenges. This "concierge" or "bulldozer" parenting prevents kids from learning self-resilience and coping mechanisms. Galloway points out the challenge of allowing children the freedom to fail in order to grow.

The Role of Technology in Modern Loneliness 13:02

"We are every day up against the deepest pocketed, most talented organizations in history that are all trying to sequester you from the most meaningful thing in your life — your relationships."

  • Galloway highlights a significant shift caused by social media and technology, which has contributed to increased depression and anxiety, particularly among young boys. He suggests that the allure of digital interactions can lead young men to forgo meaningful real-life connections in favor of superficial online experiences.

Understanding Male Discontent in Society 15:01

"We don't have a homeless or an opiate problem in the US; we have a male opiate and a male homeless problem."

  • Galloway expresses concern over the rising issues faced by young men in America, mentioning alarming statistics regarding male addiction and homelessness. He relates to these struggles personally, reflecting on his own experiences as a young man without many opportunities and the societal pressures that young boys face today.

The Complexity of Masculinity and Societal Expectations 16:50

"Unfortunately, we've created this zeitgeist of oppressed versus oppressor, and I think a lot of young men have started to get confused messages around mating and their role in society."

  • The conversation shifts to the societal narrative surrounding masculinity, with Galloway stressing that young men are often caught in conflicting messages about their identities. He argues that this confusion reflects broader cultural dynamics and has implications for their relationships and self-worth.

The Dialogue on Men’s Issues Has Evolved 17:50

"If five years ago, if you brought up or in any way advocated for men, I was called Andrew Tate with an MBA."

  • Galloway notes that discussions surrounding men’s issues and fatherhood have become more accepted over time. He reflects on the initial backlash he faced when he began addressing these topics, highlighting a gradual shift toward more constructive dialogue as society begins to recognize the challenges young men face.

The Impact of Women’s Rights on Society 18:25

"We have benefited enormously from the progress of women, but it's not a zero-sum game."

  • Scott Galloway discusses the importance of recognizing that the advancement of women's rights in the workplace during the '60s, '70s, and '80s has significantly bolstered the economy.

  • He emphasizes the need for a balanced approach that nurtures both women and men, stating that young men are currently "flailing" and that society will not flourish if they continue to struggle.

  • Galloway points out that young women desire economically and emotionally viable partners, indicating a collective interest in helping young men succeed.

Personal Reflections on Fatherhood and Relationships 19:03

"Instead of keeping score on your marriage, ask yourself: what kind of husband do you want to be?"

  • Galloway reflects on his own relationship with his father, acknowledging a distanced bond due to a lack of affection and involvement.

  • He shares an epiphany he experienced where he decided to focus on being a loving son rather than judging his father's shortcomings.

  • This new perspective significantly improved their relationship, suggesting that individuals in relationships should concentrate on what they want to contribute rather than keeping score.

The Role of Male Role Models 22:34

"When a boy loses a male role model through divorce, death, or abandonment, at that moment, he becomes more likely to be incarcerated than graduate from college."

  • Galloway highlights a critical factor impacting young men: the absence of male role models. He notes that when boys lack these figures in their lives, their chances of academic success drastically decrease.

  • He contrasts this with the outcomes for girls in similar situations, who may face different challenges yet do not show the same academic decline as boys.

  • Galloway emphasizes the necessity for communities, particularly mothers, to acknowledge that boys need male influences in their lives to help guide them through difficult transitions.

Personal Anecdote on Fatherhood 23:41

"My father was a much better father to me than his father was to him."

  • Galloway shares personal anecdotes about his father and recognizes his attempts to provide a nurturing environment, despite not being physically affectionate.

  • He reflects on the lessons learned from his father, particularly the value of storytelling and public speaking, traits he admires and has inherited.

  • He consciously chooses to be emotionally and physically affectionate with his own children, striving to provide them with reassurance and love that he felt was lacking in his own upbringing.

The Impact of Women's Workforce Participation on Birth Rates 28:07

"I think there's no doubt that if women are in the workforce and find their purpose elsewhere, it will result in lower birth rates."

  • The decline in birth rates has been attributed to the increased participation of women in the workforce, rising from 35% in 1950 to 70% today. As women gain economic independence, they may prioritize career over starting a family.

  • While this shift contributes to lower birth rates, some view it as a positive advancement for women, allowing them to become less dependent on men for economic security.

  • Economic independence has changed the dynamics of relationships, as women now demand more from men, feeling less "trapped" in traditional roles. This has led to increased divorce rates, as many view marriage as an enhancement rather than a commitment.

Men's Need for Relationship and Economic Asymmetry 31:30

"Men need relationships more than women."

  • Men historically have a greater dependency on relationships, often channeling their energy into unproductive activities when lacking romantic partnerships.

  • Studies show that men benefit more from being in a relationship than women do, living longer and experiencing greater happiness within stable partnerships.

  • The discussion highlights the necessity for men to "level up" and improve themselves to attract women, especially as women no longer feel the societal pressure to reproduce or rely on men for financial support.

Strategies for Young Men to Succeed in Dating 35:14

"If you work out three or more times a week, and engage in activities outside the house, you're immediately in the top 5% of men."

  • Young men are encouraged to focus on self-improvement through consistent exercise, working outside the home, and engaging in community activities. These efforts can significantly increase their desirability and success in dating.

  • The speaker describes a concept called "the rule of threes," where maintaining these activities places men in a position to break free from involuntary celibacy, leading to more fulfilling relationships.

The Agency of Men in Modern Society 35:48

"Most men claiming to be incels, it's like, 'Boss, this is on you.'"

  • Scott Galloway asserts that many young men who identify as incels often overlook their own agency in the dating landscape. He emphasizes that while there are obstacles facing men today, they have more personal responsibility to improve their circumstances than men in previous generations. Galloway highlights a statistic: in America, only 40% of men historically have reproduced, while the current number is now at 75%. This indicates that there are opportunities available for men if they choose to pursue them.

  • He notes that the rise of women's independence is a positive development, urging men to adapt and "level up." This means enhancing their personal and social skills to form better relationships.

Contrasting Masculine Narratives 36:31

"On one side, you have feminism claiming equal power, and on the other, a reckless attitude toward women."

  • The conversation covers the dichotomy in modern masculine narratives, where one extreme promotes a feminist ideology asserting equality, while the other adopts a negative view of women as self-serving. Galloway points out that both narratives are misleading and need to be re-examined.

  • He describes how some men are influenced by a "Playboy model," advocating for short-term sexual encounters without emotional commitment, suggesting that this mentality is becoming increasingly popular.

The Role of Faith in Relationships and Society 37:18

"Church attendance at an all-time low is not good for America."

  • Galloway discusses the relevance of faith and religious institutions in fostering community among men and women. He argues that the decline in church attendance correlates with societal issues, emphasizing the significance of belonging to a group that shares moral values and a desire to better the community.

  • He recounted experiences from his own life, mentioning exposure to various religious practices and recognizing the positives derived from them. Galloway encourages young men to engage with religious institutions as a means to find structure and support.

Men Demonstrating Excellence in Relationships 40:55

"Men need venues to demonstrate excellence."

  • Galloway highlights the necessity for men to find spaces where they can showcase their skills and growth. He notes that dating dynamics have shifted, with online interactions reducing opportunities for men to present their true selves, leading to a "mating crisis."

  • He argues that traditional meeting grounds, such as religious institutions, allow men to display qualities that attract partners, stating that environments supporting personal excellence are crucial for healthy relationship development.

Economic Viability and Relationship Dynamics 43:37

"Young men need a plan to be economically viable."

  • Galloway emphasizes the importance of economic stability as a factor that women consider when choosing a partner. He insists that men should have a plan for their financial future, even if it means temporarily inverting traditional roles within a household.

  • He points out that while economic factors play a significant role in romantic relationships, men often undervalue this aspect. Galloway encourages young men to pursue career paths that ensure they can take responsibility for their household's economic health.

The Struggles of Young Men in Finding Relationships 44:20

"Sometimes all women want is a man that's got a vision, selling a vision. They need to have a man be in pursuit of a vision and a dream, whatever that may be."

  • There is an emerging concern about young men struggling to find mates, particularly in modern society. This issue is exacerbated by changing expectations surrounding masculinity and relationships.

  • For many young women, having a partner with ambition and a clear vision for the future is increasingly important. This pursuit of aspirations becomes a fundamental characteristic sought in a relationship.

The Importance of Role Models and Education 49:50

"The K through 12 primary education system in America is biased against boys."

  • The education system currently favors traits that are more common among girls, which can disadvantage boys who are typically more active and kinetic learners.

  • Statistics show that 89% of elementary school teachers are women, which may lead to a lack of understanding regarding boys' behavior and needs in the classroom. This gender disparity has implications for how boys are managed within the school environment.

  • Boys are often likely to be suspended for similar behaviors that might not result in the same consequences for girls, indicating a systemic bias against boys in disciplinary approaches.

Addressing Educational Inequities for Boys 51:10

"We need to get more men involved in K through 12."

  • Suggestions to rectify the imbalance include redshirting boys to start school later, ensuring that they are ready for the academic environment, and increasing male representation among educators.

  • Men typically serve as vital role models and coaches, often having a positive impact on boys’ development. Financial incentives could encourage more men to take on these roles, promoting a more balanced educational environment for both genders.

Investment Strategies and Wealth Creation 53:24

“If you expect to be in the top 10%, much less the top 1% from an influence or economic standpoint, you’re going to have to work your ass off.”

  • Success in wealth building requires a significant commitment to hard work over an extended period, often 20 to 30 years.

  • Individuals seeking financial security should focus on their career and invest serious time into mastering their field.

  • It’s important to have realistic expectations about financial success; simply pursuing balance may not lead to wealth.

“Your job in your 20s is to find something you’re good at where you could be in the top 1%.”

  • Young adults should prioritize finding and excelling in a field where they can become exceptional, rather than just following their passions.

  • Understanding personal strengths can lead to successful career choices, as illustrated by the speaker’s journey from sports aspirations to academia and entrepreneurship.

“Find something you can be in the top 1% with at least a 90% employment rate.”

  • The speaker emphasizes the importance of choosing careers with high demand to ensure economic stability. Fields like tax law may offer higher returns, as success rates diminish in more saturated industries like entertainment and sports.

The Importance of Financial Discipline 55:52

“Start putting $10, $50, $100, then, if you can, $1,000 a month aside in low-cost index funds.”

  • Investing regularly in low-cost index funds is crucial for long-term wealth accumulation.

  • Young individuals should develop financial disciplines, such as forgoing daily luxuries, to build a solid financial foundation early in life.

“You do not realize how fast time will go.”

  • Emphasizing the urgency of starting to save and invest early, the speaker reflects on how quickly youth passes.

  • The earlier investments are made, the more significant the compound growth can be over time.

Lessons from Personal Experience 57:22

“Don’t be like me and go all in on things.”

  • The speaker shares personal experiences of financial setbacks due to a lack of diversification, highlighting the importance of balancing risk across investments.

  • They note having gone broke twice due to concentrated investments in technology and urge future investors to spread their risks.

“Put stuff away. Ignore it. Low-cost index funds.”

  • There’s a strong recommendation for setting aside a portion of investments to allow them to grow passively over time.

  • This strategy, coupled with patience and discipline, can lead to financial security regardless of whether one attains huge financial success.

The Role of Resilience in Success 59:31

“99% of people aren’t willing to get out a spoon and eat.”

  • Resilience is a crucial trait for success; those willing to seek out opportunities and endure rejection often find greater success than their peers.

  • Effective networking and outreach are keys to professional success, and fortitude in handling rejection is essential to overcome the majority of objections.

“You’ve got to be willing to endure the no’s.”

  • The ability to persist despite failure can differentiate those who succeed from those who do not.

  • Successful individuals often face numerous rejections before attaining significant opportunities, highlighting the importance of perseverance in achieving their goals.

Importance of Scott Galloway's Insights 01:01:25

"For the hour that we had together, it was phenomenal."

  • Patrick Bet-David expresses his admiration for Scott Galloway’s insights during their conversation. He emphasizes the need for the audience to engage with Galloway’s work, particularly the book "Notes on Being a Man."

  • Bet-David highlights that this book is a crucial resource for both young men and fathers, suggesting that the lessons within can help in successfully raising stronger men.

Shared American Values and Backgrounds 01:01:50

"My parents are immigrants. It sounds like you're an immigrant. We have more in common than separates us."

  • Galloway acknowledges a shared experience and common ground between diverse perspectives in America, emphasizing unity despite political differences.

  • He reflects on his immigrant background, highlighting that it forms a part of a collective identity that transcends individual differences, fostering a sense of community among listeners.